Week of October 1, 2008
Can an award-winning
documentary about the private politics of heterosexual
sex and its impact on the mind-blowing rise of HIV in
New York City among African-American women, get a second pass
at art theaters around the country?
Several days ago, I was fortunate enough to have read a New
York Times Arts Review of the touching but socially and
emotionally challenging documentary All of Us; a film
about the skyrocketing rise of HIV in the African American
heterosexual female community by newcomer, director Emily Abt.
So out into the rain I went, arriving at the theater early,
expecting the glowing review to have triggered a crowd of
interested New Yorkers. hardly.

The film was released to little fanfare this past week and ran
a brief seven or eight days at the 12th Street Cinema in
the Village, closing last weekend. Emily Abt spoke sweetly at
the lightly attended screening before the movie began. Several
members of WISH NY (The Women's Initiative to Stop HIV
in New York) spoke passionately about this local health crisis
afterward, introducing the film's "sHero," Chevelle, who was
sitting in the audience.
Heartbreaking is an understatement for the tragedy that
befalls the vulnerable African-American female community in
the Bronx that is finding itself ravaged by the
sexually-transmitted disease for which there is no cure.
Why us? the film probes.
Each year, more than 66% of new AIDS cases in New York are to
African-American women. As about 10% of the total New
York City population, the statistic illustrates just how out
of control HIV is in the African-American female community in
NYC. Just where it seems to be declining among every other
group in the city, it is quietly destroying the black
community.
The documentary traces this new and troubling trend through
the grinding work of a young, female, Harvard-trained,
African-American doctor of Ethiopian descent, Dr. Mehret
Mandefro. The good doctor manages to snag a coveted
Robert Wood Foundation Grant for her development of the
women's "Truth Circle," where women discuss losing control of
the actual sex act by yielding their leverage to demand condom
use during sex. Several women's lives are explored in
light of AIDS' debilitating effect on the female body and
spirit following consensual sex with a known infected partner.
Why do we willing do this? the film asks. The answers to this
question are not easy to digest, as they are intertwined with
feelings of loneliness, lack of self-esteem and early sexual
abuse. The documentary pretties up none of this.
As the subject matter would not permit me to consider the film
traditionally entertaining, the topic, the crafting of the
storyline, the film's pacing, the character development and
the overall message are exceptional.
Currently, you can view the film on YouTube and get more
information about it through the All of Us Facebook
page.